Most People Fear Narrow LinkedIn Positioning For The Wrong Reason
Staying Broad Feels Safer Because You Can See What You Might Lose
You think, “If I say consultants, what about coaches?” Then, “If I focus on LinkedIn positioning, what about my other services?” And, “If I become known for this problem, will people stop asking me about everything else?”
Those losses are easy to picture. You can name the people you might exclude and the work that disappears.
What’s harder to picture is the buyer who visited your profile, couldn’t tell why you were the right person, and left. Or the reader who liked several posts but never became clear on what you were especially useful for. Nothing happened, so there’s no loss to count.
That makes staying broad feel safer than it is. Most people don’t fear narrow positioning because they’ve proven it will hurt their business. They fear the loss they can imagine more than the cost they can’t see.
You Notice The Opportunity You Turn Down. You Don't Notice The One That Never Starts.
Say you narrow your positioning toward consultants. A coach asks whether you work with coaches, and you say no. That loss is obvious. There was a person, a conversation, and work you could have accepted.
Now consider what happens with a broad position: “I help entrepreneurs, creators, coaches, consultants, and businesses grow through marketing, content, branding, and AI.”
A consultant visits your profile and leaves without contacting you. You never know they considered you. You don’t know they couldn’t see a strong enough reason to choose you. And you’ll never know whether clearer positioning would have changed that decision.
That difference matters because only one loss leaves evidence.
The opportunity you reject leaves evidence. The opportunity that never develops usually doesn’t.
That’s why broad positioning can feel safer without proving that it produces more business. Will Narrow LinkedIn Positioning Limit My Opportunities? looks more closely at what narrowing can actually change about the opportunities available to you.
“But I Can Help Them Too” Is Usually Where The Position Starts Expanding
You start with a position: “I help consultants turn their expertise into LinkedIn content that attracts clients.”
Then the exceptions start showing up in your head:
“But I can help coaches too.”
“Creators could use this.”
“Agency owners have the same problem.”
“I also help with email.”
“AI is part of what I do.”
“I don’t want to leave digital products out.”
Soon, the position becomes: “I help entrepreneurs and brands grow through content, marketing, AI, and strategy.”
Notice what happened. None of those additions were made because consultants needed more information. They were added because leaving possibilities outside the message felt uncomfortable. Each addition protected something you might want later, while making the position broader now.
When you feel tempted to add another audience, service, or result, ask: “Does my primary buyer need this information to understand why I’m relevant, or am I adding it because I’m afraid somebody else won’t feel included?”
That’s the kind of distinction the Positioning Worksheet helps you make before fear expands the message.
Staying Broad Has A Cost Even When Nobody Tells You
Instead of asking only, “What could I lose if I narrow?” compare that risk with what staying broad is costing you.
If you narrow, ask:
Which people will feel less directly addressed?
Which services will become less visible?
Which opportunities might become less likely?
Do I want more of those opportunities?
Then look at the other side:
How quickly can someone tell what I’m known for?
How often do I change subjects because almost everything fits?
Does my profile make one important problem obvious?
Are the buyers I want giving me reasons to believe the broad position is working?
Am I protecting possibilities that rarely turn into business?
Narrowing doesn’t automatically win this comparison. The point is to count both sides instead of treating possible exclusion as the only risk.
How Do I Position Myself On LinkedIn Without Niching Down Too Far? goes deeper into creating boundaries without unnecessarily limiting the business.
Don’t compare narrow positioning with imaginary unlimited opportunity. Compare it with what your current broad positioning is actually producing.
Choose What You Want More Of, Not Everything You Want To Keep Possible
Choosing a clear position gets easier when you stop asking how many possibilities you can preserve and start asking what kind of work you want your LinkedIn presence to create more often.
Use that direction to make four decisions:
Look at the work you most want more of. Not every project you could perform.
Identify the people most likely to need that work. Not everyone who could benefit.
Choose the problem you want your name connected with. Not every problem you can solve.
Build your primary position around that direction. Let other skills support it instead of competing for equal attention.
That doesn't mean refusing adjacent clients, deleting useful skills, promising you'll never change direction, or pretending you can solve only one problem. You're deciding what gets the strongest emphasis.
The Content Authority System is built to help you keep that direction while using different content angles, situations, and lessons to strengthen it over time.
You don't have to keep every possibility visible to keep it possible.
The Bigger Risk May Be The Business You Never Realize You Lost
Narrow positioning can involve tradeoffs. Some people may feel less directly addressed or included.
But staying broad has tradeoffs too. They're harder to notice because nobody tells you when unclear positioning kept interest from becoming a client or sale.
The question isn't whether narrowing carries zero risk. It's whether keeping every possibility visible forever is worth weakening the direction you want LinkedIn to support.
Before worrying about everyone you might lose by becoming more specific, account for the right people who may already be passing you by because you haven't.
Comments
Post a Comment